History and Present Joy
“Once, perched perilously on the rocks, we laughed fondly at the thought of a child. At Cape Point where the oceans meet and part. The Indian and the Atlantic, fighting for their separate identities, roared and thrashed fiercely …. It is said that if you shut one eye and focus the other carefully, the line separating the two oceans may rear drunkenly but remains very clear and hair fine. But I did not look. In the mischievous wind I struggled with the flapping ends of a scarf I tried to wrap around my hair.” Zoe Wicomb
Engaging with social history, politics and culture as visitors is a delicate business. How can we ask questions, observe, make meaning of what we see in the present as we engage with community and governmental institutions sensitive to their portrayals of a past? How can we faithfully explore without consuming what we see, what we hear and admittedly, the adventures we undertake in a new place? The construct of the visitor and the witness allows us to rejoice in joy, beauty and the richness of connections without falling subject to the bewitching temptation of the construct of the exotic in what we experience as new and different.Derek Graf --
My first impression of the class title “Writing as a Witness” was something along the lines of “What does that even mean?” Whatever it was, it sounded serious. I couldn’t help but wonder what I had gotten myself into. Was I going to be reading during all my time abroad? Cooped up in the hotel room, next to a dim lamp with tired eyes, trying to digest a heady philosophical text?
I couldn’t really grasp what the class was about until I talked to Jennifer Keating myself. It was then when she clarified that the class was formatted to put the students in a position where they would be a witness to different facets of South African history and society. While in South Africa, I quickly realized the facets she was referencing were the depressing, albeit highly educational, aspects of the long colonial and bloody apartheid histories. We would learn about the histories and then see the direct effect of said histories right outside the museum doors.
Aside from the museums however, we were heavily encouraged to go and explore the cities, to make plans during our free days or afternoons. We would go to bars, try the local wine and food. We would do plenty of hiking, sometimes bringing enough water and snacks and other times we were not so prepared. Occasionally we would chew the fat with South African locals or other visitors, converse about what we must do or try during our time there or perhaps [just take in] the beauty of the country.
As students, we thought we were pulling a fast one. Our silly professors were actually encouraging us to push off assignments to go explore the city and stuff our faces with delicious food? Their encouragement met little resistance, "Sure thing professor, I can absolutely go check out a jazz bar tonight on my own instead of that paper you asked me to do. Doctor’s orders after all. You’re right, what’s a day late when you’re in a foreign country?"
I didn’t begin to realize I was falling directly into the trap the class had set until I started citing examples of what I saw on my adventures during class. Maybe I’d bring up a comment from a local that seemed related to apartheid, or perhaps the noticeable beautiful green spaces of one part of Cape Town compared to another.
Hook, line, and sinker. Of course, this subconscious witnessing was planned by the professors all along. But I was none the wiser until I got first-hand experiences. At the end of the trip, I was able to reflect on how much I had learned about South African politics, social justice, and beauty under the concept of “witnessing,” despite having that label take a back seat for most of the trip.
SOUND FILE
This page has paths:
- Connectivity Maya Valletta